Unbiased Cat Food Reviews

Find the best cat food for your cat from 3000+ products and 180+ brands.

If you're concerned about proper feline nutrition, ingredient quality, allergies, nutrition profiles, weight loss or simply feeding your finicky cat, the CatFoodDB is the perfect research tool to help you find the best cat foods - the ones that meet your cat's individual needs.

CatFoodDB: Decoding nutrition labels so you don't have to!

BLUE Buffalo Cat Food Reviews


According to their website, all BLUE Buffalo products are manufactured in the United States and do not contain chicken or poultry by-product meals, corn, wheat or soy in any of their recipes.


BLUE Buffalo Review Summary

Overall, with 89 varieties reviewed producing an average score of 5.4 / 10 paws, BLUE Buffalo is a below average overall cat food brand when compared to all others brands in our database.

However, due to the nature of their ingredient composition dry foods typically score less than wet foods on average. Hence, it's often helpful to break down the ratings into wet and dry food categories in order to get a more complete understanding of how the brand rates.

Of these 89 products, 49 are wet foods. These wet foods scored on average 5.8 / 10 paws, making BLUE Buffalo a below average wet cat food brand when compared against all other wet food manufacturer's products.

Hence, the remaining 40 products are dry foods, and scored an average of of 4.8 / 10 paws, making BLUE Buffalo an average dry cat food brand when compared against all other dry food manufacturer's products.

You can find more information on CatFoodDB's rating system by clicking here.

Click on any product below for our in-depth, fact-based, unbiased cat food review!


BLUE Buffalo Basics Grain-Free Indoor Duck & Potato Entrée
BLUE Buffalo Basics Grain-Free Indoor Fish & Potato Entrée
BLUE Buffalo Basics Grain-Free Indoor Turkey & Potato Entrée
BLUE Buffalo Basics Grain-Free Indoor Turkey & Potato Entrée For Kittens
BLUE Buffalo Freedom Flaked Grain-Free Chicken Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free Indoor Chicken Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free Indoor Chicken Recipe For Kittens
BLUE Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free Indoor Chicken Recipe For Mature Cats
BLUE Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free Indoor Fish Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Beef Entrée
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Chicken Entrée For Kittens
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Flaked Chicken Entrée
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Flaked Fish & Shrimp Entrée
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Flaked Tuna Entrée
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Grilled Chicken Entrée
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Grilled Salmon Entrée
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Indoor Chicken Entrée
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Indoor Chicken Entrée For Mature Cats
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Indoor Salmon Entrée
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Meaty Morsels Chicken Entrée
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Meaty Morsels Tuna Entrée
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Ocean Fish & Tuna Entrée
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Turkey & Chicken Entrée
BLUE Buffalo Natural Veterinary Diet Gi Gastrointestinal Support
BLUE Buffalo Natural Veterinary Diet Hf Hydrolyzed For Food Intolerance
BLUE Buffalo Natural Veterinary Diet K+M Kidney + Mobility Support
BLUE Buffalo Natural Veterinary Diet Np Novel Protein Alligator
BLUE Buffalo Natural Veterinary Diet W+U Weight Management + Urinary Care
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness - Turkey Turkey Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Chicken Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Chicken Recipe For Kittens
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Chicken Recipe For Mature Cats
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Denali Dinner With Wild Salmon, Venison & Halibut
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Duck Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Flatland Feast With Turkey, Quail & Duck
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipe Flaked Red Meat Feast
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipe Flaked Trout Feast
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipe Red Meat Feast
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipe Trout Feast
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Salmon Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Salmon Recipe For Kittens
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Wild Delights Chicken & Turkey Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Wild Delights Flaked Chicken & Trout For Kittens
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Wild Delights Flaked Chicken & Trout Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Wild Delights Flaked Chicken & Turkey Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Wild Delights Meaty Morsels Chicken & Salmon Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Wild Delights Meaty Morsels Chicken & Trout Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Wild Delights Minced Chicken & Trout Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Wild Delights Minced Chicken & Turkey Recipe

BLUE Buffalo Basics Grain-Free Duck & Potato Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Basics Grain-Free Indoor Fish & Potato Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Basics Grain-Free Indoor Turkey & Potato Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Basics Grain-Free Turkey And Potato Recipe For Mature Cats
BLUE Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free Indoor Chicken Recipe (Dry)
BLUE Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free Indoor Chicken Recipe For Kittens (Dry)
BLUE Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free Indoor Chicken Recipe For Mature Cats (Dry)
BLUE Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free Indoor Fish Recipe (Dry)
BLUE Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free Indoor Weight Control Chicken Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Aging Chicken & Brown Rice For Mature Cats
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Growth Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe For Kittens
BLUE Buffalo Healthy Living Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Indoor Hairball & Weight Control Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Indoor Hairball Control Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Indoor Hairball Control Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe For Mature Cats
BLUE Buffalo Indoor Health Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Indoor Health Grain-Free Chicken Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Indoor Health Salmon & Brown Rice Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Multi-Cat Health Chicken & Turkey Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Natural Veterinary Diet Gi Gastrointestinal Support (Dry)
BLUE Buffalo Natural Veterinary Diet Hf Hydrolyzed For Food Intolerance (Dry)
BLUE Buffalo Natural Veterinary Diet K+M Kidney + Mobility Support (Dry)
BLUE Buffalo Natural Veterinary Diet Np Novel Protein Alligator (Dry)
BLUE Buffalo Natural Veterinary Diet W+U Weight Management + Urinary Care (Dry)
BLUE Buffalo Sensitive Stomach Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Weight Control Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Chicken
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Chicken For Kittens
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Chicken For Mature Cats
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Denali Dinner With Wild Salmon, Venison & Halibut (Dry)
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Duck
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Flatland Feast With Turkey, Quail & Duck (Dry)
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Indoor Chicken
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Indoor Hairball & Weight Control Chicken Recipe
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Indoor Hairball Chicken
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipe Rabbit
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipe Red Meat
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipe Trout
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Salmon
BLUE Buffalo Wilderness Weight Control Chicken


About Our Ratings

At CatFoodDB, we calculate two ratings for each product. These values are then combined to create the the overall product score.

The first rating is based on the product's ingredient list. Each cat food product is assigned a value from (low) to (high) paws. Generally speaking, higher ratings are rewarded to those products that contain quality proteins and limit the amount of cheap fillers in their most plentiful ingredients.

The second rating is based on our analysis of the product's published nutritional information. Higher rated products will contain more protein and fewer carbohydrates than average. Each product is assigned a score from to paws based on this nutritional analysis. Please note that the nutritional values used are only an approximation and may not represent "as fed" values due to variations in manufacturing and the laws that specify how these values are reported.

Finally, the nutrition and ingredient ratings are added together to create a score ranging from 1 - 10 paws for the evaluated product.

Please note that although a high score may be indicative of a higher-quality product it is not a guarantee. Similarly, a low score does not necessarily indicate an inferior product. The best food for your cat is the one that meets their individual needs.


Want CatFoodDB in your inbox?

Sign up to be notified when we publish new cat food reviews and other ways to help you feed your cat.

NEW! Have a dog?

Check out our sister site!